Joshua Trees Flower Episodically in Arizona

Intro

Joshua trees are large, visually-striking trees in the Mojave desert.  Most of them are in California and Nevada, but there is also a population in the western part of Arizona.  They are frequently photographed and there are more than 17,000 observations (1,000 in AZ) saved on iNaturalist, a website and app used to document biodiversity.  

Arizona Joshua Tree locations observed on iNaturalistiNaturalist.

Joshua trees produce showy clusters of white flowers at the tips of their branches in March, but this year I noticed they were not flowering.  I wondered how often they produce flowers and decided to answer this question using data from iNat.

53 observations in Arizona showed evidence of flowering, always in March and April.  

Methods

iNat observations of Joshua Trees (Yucca brevifolia) in Arizona were marked using the Plant Phenology option in the Annotation Field.  Plant phenology (flower budding, flowering, or fruiting) was determined based on visual inspection of the saved photos in iNat.

The iNat website has a nice phenology visualization tool.  This view is filtered to show only Arizona observations.  However, it cannot show differences in phenology from one year to the next.  

Observations were then filtered on the iNat Explore page by adding &term_id=12&term_value_id=13 to the URL and downloaded for analysis in Excel.

More info about using iNat search URLs.

Results

I graphed the results starting in 2017, because there are fewer iNat observations before 2017.  It appears Joshua Trees flower episodically.  According to this data, Joshua Trees flowered in four out of the last 7 years.  They appear to alternate years from 2017-2020, but then skipped 2021 and flowered in both 2022 and 2023.  

It is interesting to note that the Arizona Joshua Trees didn't flower in 2020, which was one of the wettest springs in the last 10 years. I wonder whether the spring moisture determines flowering, or if perhaps other climate variables, such as moisture in the fall, are more important.  Another possibility could be that the trees are only able to flower every other year, and that the trees were inhibited from flowering in 2020 because of the large number that flowered in 2019.  

According to this data they were able to flower in both 2022 and 2023, but at reduced numbers both years.  Perhaps the plants flowering in 2023 were different from the trees that had already flowered in 2022?  I can't answer that question with this iNat data.  While it appears that the areas of flowering in 2022 and 2023 were the same, not all of the Joshua trees in a given area necessarily flower, even in good years...