Plant-Pollinator Interactions in Yavapai County, AZ

 Introduction

Pollinators visit plants seeking nectar and/or pollen. Pollinators include insects (e.g. butterflies, moths, beetles, bees, wasps, flies), bats, and birds. In any geographic region, native and non-native pollinators visit native and non-native plants.

Pollinators may be specialists and/or generalists who visit plants for different reasons. For example, some pollinators specialize on the pollen of certain plant species such that they visit only certain plants to harvest pollen from them. These pollen-seeking specialists may be nectar-seeking generalists to the extent that they indiscriminately harvest nectar from any plant species.

Pollinator-plant interactions are a subject of ongoing study. In North America alone there are more than 3,600 bee species. Ecologists document pollinator-plant interactions to understand which pollinators visit which plant species and why.

Methods

We use iNaturalist—a citizen science computer application—to document our observations of pollinators and plants in the places we visit. We have five years of non-systematic observation data from Yavapai County, AZ that we use for our analysis. We looked at which plant species are most frequently visited by pollinators across different taxa. This will help us better understand which local plant species are popular amongst pollinators.

We annotated five years of pollinator observation records from Yavapai County, AZ with the scientific name of the plant species each pollinator is visiting. Our database includes a total of 265 distinct counts of pollinator-plant interactions (note this is different from the number of observations).

Here is a link to our current plant-pollinator interactions in iNat.

There are some notable issues that exist with our data:

·        We did not systematically collect the data. We did not employ ecological sampling methods, we did not sample data at regular intervals of time, and we did not take measures to ensure we systematically sought observations of pollinators across distinct plant taxa in unbiased ways. Therefore, our dataset contains bias.

·        We are analyzing our dataset for fun. Since the data contain unintentional bias, we do not intend for the results of our analysis to be reliable for landscape or species management decisions.

·        Our data contain blank fields (unknowns) at the level of insect taxon family, genus, and species. Because we cannot fill in the blanks with reliable data, we conduct our analysis at the level of insect taxon (e.g. insect family, genus, or species).

·        Our database’s plant records contain plant taxa information at the level of genus and species.

See this post for more thoughts on the limitations of this type of analysis.

Total insect taxa associated with plant genera

 

Count of distinct insect taxa associated with the top ten plant genera by month

This graph reflects the top ten plant genera ranked according to the counts of distinct insect taxa associated with them. In our database, we have data for many more plant genera than those shown.

The top ten plant genera include Asclepias, Baccharis, Ceanothus, Cirsium, Dalea, Ericameria, Helianthus, Hymenothrix, Machaeranthera, and Opuntia. 

There may be more associations between distinct insect taxa and plant genera during the summer months of June, July, and August but they are not reflected in this graph because we didn’t observe them due to extreme heat and/or monsoon rains.

This project and data analysis were a collaboration between Conor Flynn and Alexandra Permar.  

High Mowing's 2023 Organic Seed Catalog

 Things I learned from High Mowing Organic Seeds's 2023 Catalog

Grafting: in vegetables, only used for tomatoes. Instead of transplanting, graft onto established roots.

I remember hearing some drivel about how tomatoes aren't vegetables, they're a fruit.  But, botanically, half of the vegetables are fruits.  Beans, cucumbers, eggplant, melons, okra, peppers, pumpkins, squash, tomatoes, watermelon, zucchini.  I don't hear anyone proclaiming "green beans are fruits!"

Most category-consistent omission:  strawberry seeds. It’s a berry, not a vegetable!  Even though they are often grown as annuals, maybe they are marketed under the category of fruit trees and perennial fruit bushes...

Spinosad and Bt are popular organic insect pest controls and are non toxic to humans and, if used correctly, mostly harmless to beneficial insects. 

Most surprising omission: sweet potatoes seeds.  Maybe because HM are mostly focused on northern crops?  Also surprisingly limited selection of collard greens, okra and swiss chard.   I noticed on the HM website that all of the conference/expos they attend are in Northern-tier states.

Least surprising omission:  cannabis seeds.  Cash crop anyone?

Most interesting omission:  mushroom seeds.   Inoculant is very popular in some areas, but with mixed success.  Is the omission a sign of lack of interest?

Most organic omission:  Imperator-type carrots.  The main type sold commercially (even "baby carrots" are whittled from these), and HM has all of the other types:  Nantes, Danvers, Chantenay… the catalog sometimes references mainstream conventional varieties of other vegetables (e.g. "Payday") but doesn't include them.  Seems organic breeders have mostly focused outside the mainstream.

Interesting which vegetables don't have disease resistance traits.  Do they not need it or has it not been selected yet?

Most confusing "seeds":  potatoes.  Apparently no one grows potatoes from seed.

Lowest-common denominator certification:  Non-GMO Project.  Is this the cheapest certification or just the best marketing logo?  Either way this seems to be the go-to certification for everything.  I have friends who say they won't buy GMO.  But organic?  Regenerative?  Bee Better?  Too expensive, what, what?  I guess it does make sense for High Mowing since they sell corn and soy. 

Pollinators

I was surprised there wasn't more mention of pollinator requirements.  Which vegetables need pollinators?  All of the fruits… 

But peas and soy can self-pollinate.  Corn should be planted in blocks so it can be wind-pollinated.

Gynoecious and monoecious cucumbers need to be planted with another variety for pollination. Parthenocarpic cucumbers don't need pollinators (= good for greenhouses). 

Seedless watermelons :  one variety needs pollination from a different variety. 

The insect apocalypse is real.  This summer I heard from people in different parts of the country who had to hand-pollinate their squash because they couldn't get any fruit otherwise.  I visited a remnant prairie patch in Ohio in July that was in full flower, but completely silent and devoid of insect life.  All blooming and no buzzing.

Hybrid vs OP vs Heirloom

Seed saving controversy:  Advocates like Bill McDorman make hybrid seeds seem almost immoral.  He claims seed-saving as an inalienable right of indigenous and small-holder farmers everywhere.  But its hard.  His very interesting book* gives detailed specifications for how far apart you have to plant different varieties to avoid cross-pollinating, in-breeding depression, or outbreeding depression.  I wonder how many farmers save seed?

Descriptions in HM imply that hybrids are better than OP.  Also interesting how many varieties are protected (from seed-saving) by UP or PVP. 

References

Bill McDoman. Basic Seed Saving: Easy step by step instructions for 18 popular vegetables. 

 Attachments

Excerpt from a conventional seed catalog.